Welcome to M. L. Cutler & Co., Inc.

Established in 1959 by Martyn L. Cutler, our company has grown into a full service agency. Peter M. Cutler joined the firm in 1980, and Michael W. Pellegrini came on board in 1994. Currently, M. L. Cutler serves the insurance needs of about 3,500 individuals and families and the insurance needs of over 1,000 business concerns in New Jersey. Our Office uses state-of-the-art computer systems for record keeping, management and rating.

We are an independent Insurance Agency... We do not work for an insurance company. We work for you. If you have a loss, we follow through to see that you receive a fair, prompt settlement. We have carefully selected reputable insurance companies and place your policy with the company offering the best coverage at the best price.

Get Quote